Newly Arrived Woman Asking for the Oxycodone She Was Given After Surgery Abroad — Free SCA Practice Case
Newly arrived woman asking for the oxycodone she was given after surgery abroad
Station Timer
Golden Minute
Initial Introduction
•Introduce yourself
•Ask an open question — "How can I help you today?"
•Listen — don't interrupt
•Catch early cues
Data Gathering
History, ICE & Diagnosis
Clinical Management
Diagnosis, Plan & Decisions
Safety Net
Follow-up & Close
Five cases are free: a live 12-minute consultation with an AI patient each, marked, and no card.
Materials for Candidate
Please review before starting the consultation
Full Name
Joana Figueiredo
Age
39 years
Consultation Type
VideoAge
39
Situation
Video Consultation. Newly registered patient.
Reason for Encounter
"I need a prescription for the oxycodone I was given after my knee operation. I have only four tablets left."
Medical Records
- ●PMH: Newly registered 2 weeks ago after moving from Portugal. No previous GP records received.
- ●Medications: None recorded. Reports oxycodone tablets prescribed abroad.
- ●Allergies: NKDA (self reported).
- ●Social: Moved to the UK 5 weeks ago with her husband and 6 year old son. Works in an accounts office.
Recent Notes
- ●Registration form: Right knee surgery in Portugal 4 months ago. Discharge papers in Portuguese only.
Patient Script
For the friend playing the patient role
Character Overview: You are Joana Figueiredo, a 39 year old accounts assistant who moved from Porto to the UK five weeks ago with your husband Rui, an engineer who took a job with a wind energy company, and your son Duarte, who is 6 and has just started school. Your English is fluent with a light accent. You started a desk job with a logistics firm two weeks ago. Four months ago you tore your right anterior cruciate ligament and a cartilage tear in a fall on a hiking trip, and you had both repaired at a private hospital in Porto. You were sent home with oxycodone tablets and your surgeon's clinic kept giving you more at each follow up. You now take six a day and have four tablets left, which is under a day's worth. You are polite, organised and quietly frightened. You are not trying to trick anyone, and you bristle if you feel treated as a drug seeker. You become quieter and faster when you talk about running out. You do not apply the word dependence to yourself.
Opening Sentence: "Hello, doctor. I registered here two weeks ago. I had knee surgery in Portugal and they gave me oxycodone for the pain. I only have four tablets left, so I need a prescription today, please."
History if Asked (Data Gathering Phase)
- ●The surgery: "Four months ago, on my right knee. The ligament at the front, the ACL, was torn and the cartilage too. They used a piece of hamstring tendon. I was on crutches for six weeks."
- ●Rehabilitation: "I had physiotherapy three times a week in Porto. Then we moved and I stopped. I haven't had a session for about five weeks and I haven't found a physio here yet. I do a few of the exercises at home when I remember."
- ●The knee now: "It aches, about three out of ten at rest. Going down stairs or standing for a long time at work takes it to five or six. It swells a little by the evening if I have been on my feet. It has not locked and it has not given way."
- ●Complications: "No fever. The scars healed well and there is no redness or discharge. No pain or swelling in my calf. No chest pain or breathlessness."
- ●The oxycodone: "The box says oxycodone, ten milligrams, the ordinary tablets and not a slow release kind. I take two in the morning, two in the afternoon and two at bedtime. At the beginning it was one, twice a day. It went up slowly over the months, and it went up more in the last six weeks because of the move."
- ●Supply: "At the hospital I was given enough for two weeks. After that the surgeon's clinic gave me a new prescription every few weeks when I went for my check. The last one was just before we flew. They never questioned it and nobody ever talked about stopping."
- ●Last dose and tablets left: "I took two this morning, about an hour ago. I have four left, so tonight's dose and the morning dose and that is it."
- ●When she runs out or is late: "Once, during the move, the box was in a suitcase and I went about a day and a half without. I thought I had the flu. I was sweating, yawning, my nose was running, my stomach was cramping and I had diarrhoea. My legs were restless and I could not sleep. It went away when I took them again. That frightens me."
- ●Why she takes them: "For the knee, yes. But honestly they also make me feel calm and they help me sleep. When I am stressed I take them a bit earlier than I should. I look at the clock. I do not take them to get high."
- ●Documents: "I have the discharge summary and the operation report. They are in Portuguese. I have a card from the clinic with the surgeon's name and the hospital's phone number and email. I also have the box with my name on the label. The surgeon speaks English."
- ●Other pain medicines: "Paracetamol, which I took in the first weeks, did very little by itself. Ibuprofen upset my stomach a little in Portugal, but it was only for a few days. I have not tried a gel or anything else."
Ideas, Concerns, Expectations
Gating note: Joana does not raise any of the following herself. Each part comes out only when the doctor asks what she thinks is going on, what is worrying her, or what she was hoping for.
- ●Ideas: She thinks the knee is still healing and that the oxycodone is what allows her to work and look after Duarte. She believes the doctor can simply carry on what her surgeon started. "The surgeon gave it to me, so I thought you would just continue."
- ●Concerns: She is afraid of the flu like feeling coming back while she is at work, and she does not know how sick leave or time off for appointments works in the UK. She is afraid of the knee pain being unmanageable. She is also afraid of being labelled an addict. "I am not an addict. I am a normal person with a bad knee. But I am scared of how I felt when I ran out. And if I am ill at work, I do not even know how sick days work here."
- ●Expectations: She came for a prescription of the same tablets at the same dose, for a month, so that she does not have to think about it. "I was hoping for a month, like in Portugal."
If Asked: Medical History and Medications
Gating note: Joana answers each of these plainly when the doctor asks about it.
- ●Other health problems: "Nothing serious. No asthma, no stomach ulcers, no kidney or liver problems. Nobody has said I stop breathing at night."
- ●Medicines and supplements: "Only the oxycodone. No sleeping tablets, no tranquillisers, no pregabalin or gabapentin, no antidepressants. A multivitamin sometimes."
- ●Allergies: "None."
- ●Past substance use: "Never. I have never used any drugs. I smoked at university and stopped fifteen years ago."
- ●Family history: "My father drank heavily when I was young. Nobody else."
Mood, Alcohol and Safety
- ●Mood: "Low, since the move. I miss my mother and my friends. I cry sometimes in the car. I am not sleeping well, even with the tablets. I have never felt that life is not worth living and I would never harm myself."
- ●Alcohol: "A glass of wine, 175 millilitres, with dinner about five evenings a week. Sometimes a second glass. Never more."
- ●Driving: "I drive Duarte to school and I drive to work. I have not felt drowsy at the wheel, but I take the morning dose before I leave."
- ●Children and storage: "The box is in my handbag, or on the kitchen shelf if I am home. Duarte has never touched it. I had not thought about locking it away."
- ●Other sources: "No. I have not bought anything online or from anyone else. All of it came from the clinic."
Social History and Lifestyle Impact
- ●Work: Accounts assistant in an office, seated most of the day, in the job for two weeks. She does not know how sick leave or time off for appointments works in the UK and has not asked anyone at work, so she is worried about what she would do if she were unwell or needed time off for physiotherapy and review appointments.
- ●Home: Lives with Rui and Duarte in rented accommodation. Rui travels for work two or three days a week, so she manages school runs alone.
- ●Availability to be seen: She can come to the surgery this afternoon or tomorrow morning.
Responses to Management (The Negotiation Phase)
- ●If the doctor explains that she cannot simply continue oxycodone at the same dose for a month:
- ●Reaction: Hurt and defensive. "Do you think I am an addict? I am a patient." If the doctor stresses that the issue is that there are no records and that this type of medicine can cause the body to depend on it even when taken as prescribed: she softens. "So it is not that you do not believe me?" If the doctor accuses her, implies she is lying, or refuses without explaining: she becomes upset, repeats that she cannot manage without it, and asks whether she should go to the emergency department tonight.
- ●If the doctor offers a small, time limited supply with a plan to reduce, or a plan for managing withdrawal symptoms if no tablets are issued:
- ●Reaction: Wants details. "How many would I get? When would I come back? What happens when they are finished?" She accepts a short supply and a slow reduction that she helps to choose. "I can do it slowly if I am not suddenly in pain at work." If offered nothing at all and no cover: "So I will have the flu feeling tomorrow, at work? What do I do?"
- ●If the doctor asks to see the documents or to contact the surgeon:
- ●Reaction: Cooperative. "Yes, of course. I can send you photos of the papers and translate them. I give permission for you to write to the surgeon. His clinic answers emails quickly."
- ●If the doctor suggests other pain relief, physiotherapy or an orthopaedic review:
- ●Reaction: Interested but doubtful. "Paracetamol did not do much on its own." She accepts a regular plan with a tablet she can take safely and a gel if explained properly. "Yes, I need a physio. I stopped because of the move. Will the NHS arrange it?" She adds, "And how do I get time off for the appointments here? I do not know how it works." If the doctor suggests a different opioid, a sleeping tablet or a nerve pain tablet to replace the oxycodone: "Is that not the same problem with a different name?"
- ●If the doctor asks to examine the knee:
- ●Reaction: Agrees readily. "Yes, please. Nobody has looked at it since the move." If asked to examine herself on camera, she declines: "Can I come in instead?"
- ●If the doctor mentions mood, safe storage, alcohol, driving, or safety netting:
- ●Reaction: Receptive. "I did not think about locking it away. I will buy a box today." She says she will cut back the wine. If the doctor offers talking therapy or support: "I would like that. I have no one here to talk to." If the safety netting is vague: "What exactly should I look for, and who do I call at night?" She repeats back clear instructions.
Mark Scheme
Domain 1: Data Gathering and Diagnosis
Domain 2: Clinical Management and Medical Complexity
Domain 3: Relating to Others
Clinical Learning Points
The Core Dilemma and the Model Plan
- ●Joana is a 39 year old woman four months after ACL reconstruction who asks for oxycodone, a Schedule 2 controlled drug, which she takes at six tablets of 10 mg a day. She has four tablets left, no English records, and no UK prescriber has ever assessed her. She is probably physically dependent. The station tests whether the candidate can avoid two errors: prescribing a month of a high dose opioid on an unverified history, and refusing outright and leaving a dependent patient to withdraw alone.
- ●The model plan has seven parts. Take a focused history of the surgery, the opioid use, the source of supply and the signs of dependence. Screen for other sedatives, alcohol, mood problems and risks at home. Ask for the Portuguese documents with a translation and, with her consent, contact the surgeon. Examine the knee in person soon. Make a safe decision about today's supply. Set out a reduction and review plan with one prescriber. Offer non opioid pain control, physiotherapy, safety advice and specific safety netting.
- ●Check the formulation: she takes ordinary immediate release 10 mg tablets, which suits a short bridge. Modified release oxycodone is no longer licensed for post operative pain (MHRA, March 2025, in the BNF).
- ●Acceptable routes for today's supply: a short, time limited bridging supply of oxycodone, no more than her stated dose and ideally a little less, to a review within a few days; or no supply today, with treatment for withdrawal symptoms and a review within 24 to 48 hours. Both are defensible. The first fits NICE advice against stopping abruptly, and the second is defensible when the history cannot be relied on. A repeat prescription for a month, or a refusal with no cover and no review, is not.
Why Unverified Opioid Supply Is a Risk
- ●Oxycodone is a Schedule 2 controlled drug, so prescriptions must meet the controlled drug writing requirements. The BNF notes a strong Department of Health recommendation that no more than 30 days is prescribed, a ceiling and not a target, and it does not make a month appropriate here. A practice is not obliged to continue a medicine started abroad. A prescriber who signs takes responsibility for the decision, however it began. Nobody in the UK has assessed this patient, and nothing has been confirmed.
- ●Joana is credible and holds a labelled box, a clinic card and Portuguese papers, so doubting her is not the point. The point is that a long, escalating, high dose supply needs verification, monitoring and an end point before a new prescriber takes it over.
- ●The history contains a gap a good candidate notices. Opioids for post operative pain are meant to be short courses. The BNF, reflecting MHRA advice, says to supply only enough immediate release opioid for acute post operative pain to limit dependence, stockpiling and diversion. Four months at six tablets a day, still rising, is well outside that.
Dependence and Withdrawal
- ●The MHRA (September 2020, quoted in the BNF) warns that use beyond three months for non malignant pain carries an increased risk of dependence and addiction even at therapeutic doses, and that doses should be tapered slowly at the end of treatment, with high doses taking weeks or months.
- ●NICE NG215 (April 2022) recommends discussing withdrawal when the condition the medicine was prescribed for has resolved, when problems with dependence have developed, or when harms outweigh benefits. It reassures clinicians that dependence is an expected effect of these medicines and that language apportioning blame should be avoided.
- ●Features pointing to dependence in Joana: a dose that has tripled, early dosing under stress, clock watching, use for calm and sleep, and a withdrawal illness after about a day and a half without tablets: sweating, yawning, rhinorrhoea, cramps, diarrhoea, restlessness and insomnia. She is not currently in withdrawal because she took a dose an hour ago, but she will be within about a day.
- ●Risk factors for a difficult withdrawal (NG215 1.5.7) include long duration, high dose and a history of withdrawal symptoms. All three apply.
Verification and the Role of the Documents
- ●Ask what she holds. She has a discharge summary, an operation report, a clinic card with the surgeon's contact details and a labelled box. A translation by phone app is a reasonable start. The practice can then write to the hospital, with her consent, to confirm the operation and the prescribing history.
- ●Verification should happen in parallel with safe care. Waiting days for an overseas reply while a dependent patient runs out in a day does not help anyone.
- ●Do not rely on the box alone, or treat the lack of an English letter as proof she is lying.
Today's Decision and the Reduction Plan
- ●NG215 1.5.6 says do not stop an opioid abruptly unless there are exceptional medical circumstances, and where it is stopped consider more frequent review and short term medicines for the physical symptoms, such as cramps and diarrhoea. NG215 1.5.11 suggests a slow, stepwise reduction proportionate to the existing dose, with smaller decrements as the dose falls, unless clinical risk requires faster withdrawal.
- ●A sensible plan: a bridging supply of a few days only, reviewed in person within that time, with the examination and the documents in hand. The patient helps to choose the pace of the first steps. One named prescriber takes responsibility. The supply is written to controlled drug rules in small quantities, and colleagues and the dispensing pharmacy are told. Tapering high doses may take weeks or months, so the end point is set at the review, not at the first visit.
- ●The alternative of no supply today is acceptable if the candidate explains why, covers withdrawal symptoms, and reviews within 24 to 48 hours. A candidate who instead describes a fixed, fast cut with no review should lose marks.
- ●The reduction aims at stopping, but NG215 1.5.7 allows an initial aim of dose reduction with review if complete withdrawal proves too difficult. If tapering in primary care fails, a local drug and alcohol or specialist pain service is appropriate, as CKS Opioid dependence (revised February 2025) advises offering referral to specialist drug services where dependence is identified.
Non Opioid Pain Control and Rehabilitation
- ●Four months after ligament surgery, pain should be falling. Her pain is mild at rest and moderate on stairs, and rehabilitation stopped five weeks ago. Resuming physiotherapy is a core treatment, not an extra.
- ●Regular paracetamol, an oral anti inflammatory with stomach protection if there is no contraindication, or a topical anti inflammatory are all reasonable. Joana has no asthma, ulcer or kidney disease. Her brief ibuprofen stomach upset suggests protection if an oral one is chosen.
- ●Do not swap oxycodone for another opioid, a gabapentinoid or a benzodiazepine as a way round declining. These add risk, and NG215 and the MHRA both stress the danger of co prescribing opioids with benzodiazepines.
- ●An examination in person should check swelling, range of movement, stability, the wounds, the calf and for withdrawal signs. If it suggests the graft or meniscus is failing, an orthopaedic opinion is needed. Do not ask her to examine herself on video.
Safety, Mood and Support
- ●Advise on drowsiness, the interaction with alcohol, and driving. The BNF notes that driving law applies to certain medicines including opioids, so she should not drive if drowsy or impaired. She drives her son to school after a morning dose.
- ●She does not know how sick leave works in the UK. Explain that she can self certify for the first seven days of illness, that a fit note from the practice is needed after that, and that she can ask her employer about sick pay and time off for appointments. Offer a fit note if one is needed.
- ●Advise locked storage away from her six year old son, no sharing, and return of spare tablets to a pharmacy. She keeps the box in her handbag.
- ●Her father's heavy drinking, low mood, isolation and the stress of the move are risk factors. Ask about self harm. Offer follow up and NHS talking therapies. Do not label her.
Communication
- ●NG215 1.5.3 advises reassuring people that dependence is an expected effect of these medicines and being sensitive to terms that apportion blame. Keep her fear of being called an addict in view.
- ●She came expecting a month's supply. Explain the limit as protection, separate it from disbelief, and offer her control over the pace.
- ●If she becomes upset, stay warm and restate what can be done today. Giving in is as unhelpful as becoming cold.
- ●Check understanding with teach back, especially warning symptoms and the plan.
Common Mistakes in This Station
- ●Issuing a month of oxycodone to end the conversation, or refusing with no cover and no review.
- ●Taking the history only about the knee and missing the escalating dose, early dosing and withdrawal illness.
- ●Swapping to codeine, tramadol, gabapentinoids or a sleeping tablet to avoid the oxycodone question.
- ●Making the examination or verification a condition for any help, or examining the knee over video.
- ●Using the words addict or drug seeker, or lecturing her on opioid misuse.
- ●Forgetting the storage risk for her son, driving, alcohol, or her mood and isolation.
- ●Safety netting with come back if worse and no named symptoms or contact.
- ●Omitting physiotherapy or forgetting that one prescriber must own the plan.
Mapped to the RCGP curriculum topic: People with Long-term Conditions Including Cancer.
← Back to Free SCA Practice Cases