Low Potassium in a Young Man Preparing for a Modelling Job — Free SCA Practice Case
Young man with a low potassium who is preparing for a modelling job
Station Timer
Golden Minute
Initial Introduction
•Introduce yourself
•Ask an open question — "How can I help you today?"
•Listen — don't interrupt
•Catch early cues
Data Gathering
History, ICE & Diagnosis
Clinical Management
Diagnosis, Plan & Decisions
Safety Net
Follow-up & Close
Five cases are free: a live 12-minute consultation with an AI patient each, marked, and no card.
Materials for Candidate
Please review before starting the consultation
Full Name
Jonah Kapadia
Age
22 years
Consultation Type
TelephoneAge
22
Situation
Telephone Consultation. Same day call for blood results.
Reason for Encounter
"Ringing for my blood results. My heart keeps fluttering and I've got a shoot coming up, so I'd like something to settle it."
Medical Records
- ●PMH: Nil. No medicines. NKDA.
- ●Social: Shared house. Bike shop, models. Non smoker. 74 kg, BMI 21.9 (18 months ago).
- ●Seen 2 days ago: Three weeks of fluttering palpitations. Pulse 84 regular, BP 106/62. ECG not done. Bloods taken.
- ●Results: K 2.9 (3.5 to 5.3), bicarbonate 31 (22 to 29), urea 8.6 (2.5 to 7.8), Mg 0.62 (0.70 to 1.00). Others normal.
Patient Script
For the friend playing the patient role
Character Overview: You are Jonah Kapadia, 22, who works three days a week at a bike shop and has modelled for seven months with a small agency. You rent a shared house with Dami and Rafe, who are at work. You sound friendly, upbeat and a bit cocky about fitness and you laugh things off. You want the call short: you have a casting this afternoon and your first paid catalogue shoot in nine days.
You believe you eat "really clean" and are proud of your discipline. In reality you eat about 1300 calories a day, skip meals before castings, train about two hours most days including a fasted morning run, and weigh yourself every morning. You are 63 kilos at 184 centimetres, down from 74 when you registered at the practice. Your booker says the client likes models lean and defined. You also take senna most weeks and a water tablet before castings and shoots, to look flat and dry on camera. You do not count these as medicines and do not volunteer them, because you half suspect it would sound bad.
You are embarrassed that this is happening to a man and scared of being dropped by the agency. You never use or hint at any illness label for yourself. You answer what you are asked and no more. If the doctor sounds judgemental, you become clipped and defensive ("Everyone does it, I thought you'd get it"). If the doctor is kind, matter of fact and unshockable, you relax and tell the truth.
Opening Sentence: "Hi doctor. I'm ringing for my blood results. The other doctor did them because my heart's been fluttering, and I've got a big shoot next week, so I'd really like something to settle it down."
History if Asked (Data Gathering Phase)
- ●The palpitations: "About three weeks. My heart flutters or skips, then thumps, for a few seconds up to a minute. A few most days, after training, in the evenings and a couple in bed. I had one two hours ago. Right now I'm fine."
- ●Fainting, near fainting, chest pain, breathlessness: "I've never passed out. But four days ago in the gym I got up off the bench and everything went grey and I had to sit down for a minute. I get dizzy standing up fast. No chest pain. I'm not short of breath sat here, just a bit more puffed on my run."
- ●Family history: "Dad has type 2 diabetes. My nan had a pacemaker in her eighties. Nobody young, nobody dropping dead."
- ●Caffeine, drugs and alcohol: "A scoop of pre workout most mornings, three or four black coffees and a sugar free energy drink some afternoons. No drugs, never touched steroids. A couple of pints on a Saturday at most."
- ●What he eats (he starts with "I eat really well, honestly"): "Super clean. I track everything on an app." If asked for a typical day: "Black coffee and a protein shake in the morning. Chicken and greens for lunch, or I skip lunch if I've got a casting. Fish or eggs and veg for tea. Nothing after about six." If asked how much: "Twelve, thirteen hundred calories. I'm not even hungry, you get used to it."
- ●Weight and body image (if asked sensitively): "Sixty three kilos, weighed every morning. I was seventy four a year and a half ago. The agency want me nearer sixty and a thirty inch waist. On camera I look soft round the middle. I'm never really happy with how I look."
- ●Exercise: "Two hours most days, weights then a run, usually fasted in the morning. I only rest on a Sunday."
- ●Anything else to look leaner (a general question such as "do you do anything else for shoots?"): "Just training and eating clean. Well, and a couple of the usual things lads use before a shoot." He gives details only if asked what those are, or asked about laxatives or water tablets by name.
- ●Laxatives (only if asked about laxatives or bloating): "Senna. Everyone does it. Six or eight tablets, three or four nights a week. I started four months ago with two, but two stopped doing much. It gets rid of the bloat so I'm flat on camera." Last taken last night.
- ●Water tablets (only if asked about water tablets or diuretics): "A lad in the business gave me a strip and I've had more since. Furosemide, forty milligram. One the morning of a casting and the days before a shoot, lately two or three times a week. It drains the water so I look defined." Last taken this morning.
- ●Vomiting, diet pills, losing control (if asked): "I'd never make myself sick. No diet pills. I don't lose control."
Ideas, Concerns, Expectations
Gating note: Jonah raises none of these himself. Each comes out only when the doctor asks what he thinks is going on, what worries him, or what he was hoping for.
- ●Ideas: The pre workout and coffee mixed with nerves about the shoot, or his heart working hard because he trains so much. "Fit lads get funny hearts, don't they?"
- ●Concerns: Losing the shoot. "There's a queue of lads waiting for my slot." If the doctor explores further: "Honestly I'm a bit worried it's my heart. And I haven't told anyone about the tablets, because I'm a bloke and it sounds daft."
- ●Expectations: "Something like propranolol, one of the other lads takes it before shoots." He does not want hospital and planned to carry on training.
If Asked: Medical History and Medications
Gating note: Jonah does not count laxatives or water tablets as medicines, so a general question about tablets does not bring them out.
- ●Past history, prescribed medicines, allergies: "Nothing, no tablets from the doctor, no allergies." Thyroid, diabetes, kidney problems: "No."
- ●Other things he takes: "Just protein, creatine, a multivitamin and the pre workout."
Social History and Lifestyle Impact
Gating note: Jonah mentions these naturally when talking about the shoot or his routine, without making a speech.
- ●Home and family: Flatmates out until the evening. His parents live an hour away; mum works in a care home, dad drives a taxi. He has told them nothing and thinks his mum would panic. He has a bike and no car.
- ●Work and agency: Cycles everywhere. One small paid job so far. The booker wants a 30 inch waist and does not know about the tablets.
- ●Social life: He has stopped going out for meals. Nobody knows his routine; flatmates think he is strict.
- ●Mood and sleep (if asked): "Wired and snappy, stressed about the shoot. I wake early, starving." Low mood: "Not really, a bit down when I look in the mirror." Self harm: "No. Never."
If Asked: Associated Symptoms
Gating note: Jonah answers direct symptom questions in one or two sentences.
- ●Cramps, weakness, tiredness: Calves cramp at night, legs feel heavy on the bike, tired all the time. He puts it down to overtraining.
- ●Bowels, urine, thirst: Loose some mornings, sometimes nothing for a day or two (linked to senna only if asked). Up for a wee twice at night on water tablet days, thirsty, dry mouth.
- ●Other: Pins and needles in his fingers, feels the cold. No fever, tremor or heartburn.
Responses to Management (The Negotiation Phase)
- ●If the Doctor gives him a beta blocker, or says it is caffeine and nerves:
- ●Reaction: Relieved. "Brilliant. Will I be alright for the shoot, then?" If the doctor declines a beta blocker: "But another lad takes propranolol before shoots. Why can't I?" He accepts it if told it would not fix the cause and could slow the heart or drop the blood pressure while his potassium is low.
- ●If the Doctor asks about laxatives, water tablets or things for weight:
- ●Reaction: If blaming or shocked, clipped: "Everyone does it. I thought you'd understand. It's my job." If calm and matter of fact, saying many people in jobs where looks matter use them, he relaxes: "Okay. I thought you'd tell me off."
- ●If the Doctor explains the results or says he needs to be seen today:
- ●Reaction: Surprised, then resistant. "Low potassium? I eat bananas. Today? I've got a casting and I'm training at five. Can't I take a potassium tablet and come back next week?" Asked "Could I drop dead?", quiet and frightened; he steadies if told honestly that low potassium can disturb the heart rhythm, which is why it cannot wait, and that it is treatable. If told to wait for the hospital team's call, he agrees to take no tablets and not train meanwhile. On travel: "My flatmates are out. Could my mum drive up, or do I need an ambulance?" He agrees when given a practical option and clear 999 triggers.
- ●If the Doctor tells him to stop the water tablets or senna, or that they do not help weight:
- ●Reaction: Worried. "If I stop I'll puff up before the shoot, and get constipated. But I look flatter afterwards." He accepts it if told it is water, not fat, that swelling and weight rebound can follow and are not a reason to restart, and that the hospital team can help.
- ●If the Doctor raises an eating problem, a specialist service, the agency or his parents:
- ●Reaction: Defensive. "An eating problem? Isn't that a girl thing? This is just for work." He softens if told men get these too and this is about looking after his body. A specialist: "Like a psychiatrist? Would the agency find out?" Told it is confidential and neither agency nor parents will be told without his agreement, with an offer of a short letter saying only that he is unwell, he relaxes. Told the shoot depends on today's checks: "It's my only shot," but he calms if the doctor is honest and puts his health first.
- ●If the Doctor gives vague safety netting, checks understanding, or offers follow up:
- ●Reaction: "Come back if it gets worse": "Worse how? What am I looking out for?" Given clear 999 triggers he repeats the plan: "So I go in today with someone, stop the water tablets and senna, don't train, and ring 999 if it goes wrong." Offered early follow up: "Okay. I'll do it. Thanks for not making me feel like an idiot."
Mark Scheme
Domain 1: Data Gathering and Diagnosis
Domain 2: Clinical Management and Medical Complexity
Domain 3: Relating to Others
Clinical Learning Points
The Core Dilemma and the Model Plan
- ●Jonah is 22, models part time and wants a tablet for three weeks of palpitations. His potassium is 2.9 mmol/L, his magnesium is low, his bicarbonate and urea are raised, and nobody has done an ECG.
- ●Two linked tasks: act on the medical risk today, then find the cause. The cause is senna and furosemide taken to look flat and dry for castings, on top of about 1300 calories a day and two hours of training.
- ●Model plan: arrange same day assessment for an ECG, repeat potassium and magnesium and monitored correction; hand over with the full story; decline a beta blocker; no more senna, furosemide or hard training before assessment; refer to the eating disorder service; arrange follow up and 999 triggers.
- ●Acceptable alternative: speaking to the on call medical team straight away, passing on results and symptoms, and following their same day plan. A same day practice ECG may be added to either route but does not replace them.
Reading the Results
- ●NICE CKS Hypokalaemia grades potassium 3.0 to 3.4 mmol/L as mild, 2.5 to 2.9 as moderate and below 2.5 as severe, but says severity is judged from symptoms and the ECG as well as the number.
- ●Magnesium of 0.62 mmol/L is low. Hypokalaemia often cannot be corrected until magnesium is corrected: oral magnesium suits mild depletion (0.5 to 0.75 mmol/L), intravenous below 0.5 or if symptomatic.
- ●A raised bicarbonate with a raised urea fits fluid loss from a loop diuretic. Chronic laxative misuse can also cause a metabolic alkalosis, and self induced vomiting is the other classic cause, so the pattern alone does not say which behaviour is responsible.
- ●Other causes include thiazides, beta agonists, steroids, alcohol, thyrotoxicosis and renal tubular problems. His thyroid tests, glucose, calcium and creatinine are normal. Urine can be tested for laxatives and furosemide.
- ●Normal electrolytes never rule out an eating disorder, and abnormal ones are a cause for concern.
Deciding Urgency
- ●CKS says to admit immediately if potassium is below 2.5 mmol/L, if the person is symptomatic (dysrhythmia, paralysis, respiratory failure, severe weakness), if there are signs of hypovolaemia or a metabolic acidosis or alkalosis, or if magnesium is below 0.5 mmol/L. Moderate hypokalaemia without symptoms needs discussion with a specialist.
- ●The Royal College of Psychiatrists guidance on medical emergencies in eating disorders (MEED) says potassium below 3.0 mmol/L needs a medical opinion, with consideration of admission and cardiac monitoring.
- ●An ECG is needed to judge urgency. Look for ST depression, flat T waves, prominent U waves and long QT, and rhythm disturbance from ectopics to ventricular tachycardia. Syncope or near syncope with palpitations needs urgent assessment.
- ●Jonah has palpitations, a near faint four days ago, low magnesium, a raised bicarbonate and no ECG, so he needs assessment today. The primary care route (treat the cause, consider oral potassium, recheck at two weeks) is for mild or moderate hypokalaemia that does not need referral.
- ●People with eating disorders can sound deceptively well, and no single parameter measures risk.
What Hospital Treatment Looks Like
- ●Oral potassium chloride is preferred where it can be taken. Intravenous potassium is used if the person cannot take it or the deficit is severe, with continuous ECG monitoring to avoid overshoot. Typical oral doses are 24 to 36 mmol up to three or four times daily for moderate hypokalaemia, aiming for at least 3.5 mmol/L, and at least 4.0 with a dysrhythmia.
- ●Oral potassium should not be given in acute dehydration. His raised urea and dizziness on standing suggest he may be volume depleted, one more reason a tablet and a recheck is not the whole plan.
- ●The team will correct magnesium, replace fluid, look for the cause and monitor for refeeding risk.
Asking About Purging Without Accusing
- ●Ask permission, say you ask everyone, and note that people in modelling, sport and dance are often pushed to be lean. Name the methods: laxatives, water tablets, vomiting, diet pills and excessive exercise.
- ●Ask for a typical day of eating, current weight and its history, how much he trains and how he feels about his body.
- ●"Any medicines?" will not bring out laxatives or water tablets because he does not count them. "Anything you use to look leaner or more defined?" does.
- ●NICE NG69 says not to rely on BMI or screening tools alone. His BMI of about 18.6 at 63 kg would not by itself alarm, but it has fallen from 21.9.
- ●Assess mood, self harm, alcohol and drugs, and ask who knows. Secrecy and isolation matter.
Why a Telephone Call Is Not Enough
- ●NG69 and CKS list reasons to consider an ECG: rapid weight loss, excessive exercise, laxative or diuretic misuse, vomiting, bradycardia, hypotension, excessive caffeine, muscle weakness and electrolyte imbalance. Jonah has most of them.
- ●By phone you cannot weigh him, take a pulse, measure lying and standing blood pressure or do strength tests. The tested behaviour is recognising he must be seen in person today.
- ●A normal pulse and blood pressure two days ago do not exclude risk. Postural drop, ECG changes and falling potassium need repeat assessment.
Medicines: Beta Blocker, Senna and Furosemide
- ●A beta blocker can slow the heart and lower blood pressure in a man who is volume depleted, underfed and low in potassium and magnesium, and it does not treat the cause. CKS Eating disorders advises weighing the cardiac risk of malnutrition and compensatory behaviours when prescribing. His pulse of 84 and BP of 106/62 are not contraindications, so this is a judgement about cause and timing. Symptomatic treatment can be revisited after the ECG and correction.
- ●Senna is licensed at 7.5 to 15 mg at bedtime, and Jonah takes 45 to 60 mg. Prolonged use causes hypokalaemia, as does furosemide.
- ●NG69 says laxatives and diuretics do not reduce calorie absorption or help weight loss, and should be reduced and stopped gradually. CKS says to stop a medicine that may cause hypokalaemia. Both stopping now and a supported taper are guideline supported, so the plan is not marked on which. What matters is no more before assessment, and an agreed plan with specialist support.
- ●Warn him about rebound. MEED describes severe oedema after stopping diuretics or laxatives, very distressing with body image concerns. Say it is expected, not a reason to restart, and that the hospital team can help. Stopping senna can cause constipation and bloating.
- ●NG69 advises people who exercise excessively to stop, so hard training and fasted running pause until assessed.
- ●Do not give diet, weight or exercise targets. Furosemide is prescription only, so asking where he got it is reasonable, in a matter of fact tone.
Referral, Follow Up and Confidentiality
- ●NG69 recommends immediate referral to a community eating disorder service when one is suspected. CKS says not to use watchful waiting, and that early referral improves recovery. While he waits, arrange regular review of physical and mental risk and consider urgent admission if he deteriorates. The specialist team decides treatment; the GP role is recognition, physical risk, referral and continuity.
- ●Signpost Beat (helpline 0808 801 0677, 3pm to 8pm Monday to Friday) and its information for men.
- ●He is an adult with capacity. GMC guidance says to ask consent before disclosing and usually abide by a refusal, with disclosure without consent only in very exceptional circumstances. So the agency and his parents are not told without his agreement. The hospital and eating disorder teams receive what they need, and he can be told that. A short letter saying only that he is unwell can be offered.
- ●Safety net with specific 999 triggers: continuous or racing palpitations, fainting or near fainting, chest pain, severe breathlessness or severe weakness, including on the way. If he has no safe lift, call 999 rather than cycle.
Common Candidate Mistakes in This Station
- ●Accepting caffeine, anxiety or being a fit athlete as the explanation.
- ●Prescribing propranolol or bisoprolol.
- ●Oral potassium with a repeat in days or weeks, or only a practice ECG and repeat bloods with no hospital or medical team discussion that day.
- ●Not asking about laxatives, water tablets and vomiting by name, or asking so bluntly he becomes defensive.
- ●Ruling out an eating disorder because he is a man, his BMI is not low or he says he eats well.
- ●Sending him to hospital without a handover, letting him cycle there, or after the casting.
- ●Stopping the tablets with no warning about swelling and weight rebound.
- ●Giving a diet or weight target, or telling him to stop modelling.
- ●Promising he will be fine for the shoot, or saying the agency or parents will be told without consent.
- ●Safety netting with "come back if it gets worse" and no 999 triggers.
Mapped to the RCGP curriculum topic: Mental Health.
← Back to Free SCA Practice Cases