Keen Cyclist Whose Blood Pressure Monitor Flagged An Irregular Pulse — Free SCA Practice Case
Keen cyclist whose blood pressure monitor flagged an irregular pulse
Station Timer
Golden Minute
Initial Introduction
•Introduce yourself
•Ask an open question — "How can I help you today?"
•Listen — don't interrupt
•Catch early cues
Data Gathering
History, ICE & Diagnosis
Clinical Management
Diagnosis, Plan & Decisions
Safety Net
Follow-up & Close
Five cases are free: a live 12-minute consultation with an AI patient each, marked, and no card.
Materials for Candidate
Please review before starting the consultation
Full Name
Rosemary Okoro
Age
67 years
Consultation Type
VideoAge
67
Situation
Video Consultation. Booked by the practice nurse.
Reason for Encounter
"Irregular heartbeat symbol on home blood pressure monitor. Please discuss ECG and bloods."
Medical Records
- ●PMH: Hypertension. Knee osteoarthritis.
- ●Medications: Amlodipine 5 mg once daily.
- ●Allergies: NKDA.
- ●Social: Retired. Widowed, lives alone.
Recent Notes
- ●Review 13 months ago: Pulse 64 regular. Alcohol about 10 units a week.
- ●Nurse, 6 days ago: Monitor flagged irregular pulse on 11 of 14 readings. Pulse irregularly irregular, about 120. BP 138/84. Weight 64 kg.
- ●ECG: Atrial fibrillation, rate 118.
- ●Bloods: Hb 136, creatinine clearance 69 mL/min. Others normal.
Patient Script
For the friend playing the patient role
Character Overview: You are Rosemary Okoro, a 67 year old retired quantity surveyor, widowed four years ago when your husband Tunde died. You live alone and your daughter Ada lives in Glasgow. You take one blood pressure tablet each morning. You cycle about 50 miles a week with the Riverside Wheelers club, which got you out of the house after Tunde died, and in five weeks you ride the Way of the Roses, about 170 miles over four days, with eight club friends.
Your home blood pressure monitor kept showing a little heart symbol, so the nurse felt your pulse, did a heart tracing and took bloods, then booked this call. You feel completely well and hope it is the machine, or something harmless from being fit. You are bright, practical and good with numbers, and you want real figures, not vague words. You are warm but go quiet and clipped when blood thinners come up, because of Clive from your club. You do not volunteer that fear, or how much cycling means to you, until asked.
Opening Sentence: "Hello, thanks for seeing me. My blood pressure machine kept flashing a little heart symbol at me, so the nurse did a heart tracing last week and said I needed to talk to a doctor about it. I feel completely well, honestly, so I'm hoping it's just the machine playing up."
History if Asked (Data Gathering Phase)
- ●How it was found: "Nearly every reading, morning and evening, the heart symbol came up. The booklet says it means an irregular heartbeat. I changed the batteries and it still did it. The pulse numbers were high for me, a hundred and ten, a hundred and twenty. I'm normally in the sixties."
- ●Heart rate when cycling (if asked about exercise or her bike): "Funny you should ask. For a few months the heart rate on my bike computer has been all over the place. It shoots up to a hundred and eighty odd on the hills. I bought a new chest strap and it does exactly the same."
- ●Symptoms and exercise: "I can't feel anything. I rode twenty miles yesterday. I've been dropping off the back a bit on the big climbs these last few months, but I'm 67, so I put it down to age."
- ●When it started (if asked): "I couldn't tell you. Nobody's felt my pulse since my check over a year ago, and the nurse said it was fine then."
- ●Alcohol and caffeine (if asked): "A glass of red with dinner most nights, a big one at the weekend, and a pint at the café after the Sunday ride. More than I told the nurse over a year ago, if I'm honest, roughly sixteen to twenty units a week. Two coffees a day."
- ●Falls (if asked about accidents): "I came off on a wet bend in March. Grazed my hip and elbow, nothing broken, back on the bike in a fortnight. I always wear a helmet."
- ●Riding alone (if asked): "Sundays are with the club. Midweek I often go out on my own round the country lanes, ten or fifteen miles."
Ideas, Concerns, Expectations
Gating note: Rosemary does not raise any of the following herself. Each part comes out only when the doctor asks what she thinks is going on, what is worrying her, or what she was hoping for. Her fear of bleeding also comes out straight away if the doctor mentions blood thinners or anticoagulants.
- ●Ideas: She half believes the monitor is faulty. If not, she thinks it is harmless from all the cycling. "I read somewhere that very fit people can have funny heart rhythms."
- ●Concerns: Her main fear is being put on blood thinners and bleeding badly if she comes off her bike. "Clive from the club came off on a descent last year. He was on blood thinners after a clot in his leg and he ended up with a bleed on the brain. He was in hospital for weeks and he's never been back on the bike." If the doctor explores further: "I'm on my own. If I came off on a lane in the middle of nowhere and I was bleeding, who'd find me?" Underneath, she fears being told to stop cycling. "The club's my social life now."
- ●Expectations: She hopes to hear it is nothing, or at most to be given something mild. "I'm not missing the Way of the Roses."
If Asked: Medical History and Medications
Gating note: Rosemary answers each of these plainly when the doctor asks about it.
- ●Blood pressure: "Three years. I take the amlodipine every morning and it's been fine."
- ●Stroke, mini stroke, diabetes, heart attack, angina, heart failure or leg circulation: "No, none of those. No funny turns. They check my sugar every year."
- ●Murmur, rheumatic fever, valve, bleeding, kidney, liver or thyroid problems: "None that anyone's told me. No ulcers. I bruise a bit if I bang myself, nothing unusual."
- ●Painkillers (if asked about anything from the chemist): "Ibuprofen for my knees after the long Sunday ride, two of the 200s, and sometimes midweek. So two or three days a week. I didn't think that counted."
- ●Aspirin, supplements, operations, allergies: "No aspirin. Just vitamin D in winter. No operations or allergies."
- ●Family history: "My mum had a stroke at 84. She couldn't walk or talk properly and spent her last two years in a nursing home. My dad lived to 88. My brother has high blood pressure."
Social History and Lifestyle Impact
- ●Home and driving: Retired five years ago. Speaks to Ada most days, drives to the start of club rides. Never smoked. Sleeps well.
- ●Cycling: Club ride of about 30 miles on Sundays with a café stop, and two shorter solo rides midweek. The Way of the Roses is booked, with bed and breakfasts arranged. "Cycling is my social life. I honestly don't know what I'd do without it."
If Asked: Associated Symptoms
- ●Negatives, grouped: no chest pain or tightness; no breathlessness at rest, lying flat or waking at night; no swollen ankles; no dizziness, fainting or blackouts; no weakness, numbness, drooping face, slurred speech or loss of vision, even briefly; no weight loss, sweating or shakiness; no black stools, blood in stools or urine, nosebleeds or bleeding gums; no recent infection; no headaches.
Responses to Management (The Negotiation Phase)
- ●If the doctor explains that the tracing confirms an irregular rhythm and it is not the machine, or says it is harmless because she is fit:
- ●Reaction: Told it is not the machine: "Oh. So it wasn't the batteries. Is it dangerous? I'm not going to drop dead halfway up a hill, am I?" She settles if told calmly why it is not an emergency. Told it is harmless: "Thank goodness. So I don't need to do anything?" Told the main risk is a stroke: "But I feel perfectly well. I'm fitter than most people half my age." Once told that feeling well and fitness do not lower the risk, she goes quiet: "My mum had a stroke. I wouldn't wish that on anyone."
- ●If the doctor recommends a blood thinner or anticoagulant:
- ●Reaction: Her voice tightens. "I was dreading you'd say that. What happens if I come off the bike? I could bleed to death on a lane and nobody would know." Given vague words such as "a small risk": "Small compared to what? Give me the actual numbers." Given real figures for her own stroke and bleeding risk, she repeats them back to check and becomes much more open. Told that falls are not a reason to avoid it and what to do after a knock to the head: "So if I banged my head, even if I felt fine, I'd go straight to A&E and tell them I'm on it?"
- ●If the doctor suggests aspirin, offers a choice of tablet or discusses taking it:
- ●Reaction: "Couldn't I just take an aspirin instead? That's what Tunde was on, and it seemed gentler." She accepts the answer if told how much less aspirin protects and that it still causes bleeding. "Once a day or twice? What happens if I forget one?" Asked how long she would take it: "So it's for life? Will anyone ever look at it again?"
- ●If the doctor tells her to stop cycling or skip the trip, or says she can keep cycling:
- ●Reaction: Told to stop, she is upset: "Then what's the point of any of it? I'd rather take my chances than give up the bike." She becomes reluctant to take any tablet. Told she can keep cycling with practical advice, she brightens: "So I can still do the Way of the Roses? That's all I wanted to hear." She asks whether to tell the club.
- ●If the doctor raises her ibuprofen, her alcohol or a tablet to slow her heart rate:
- ●Reaction: "What do I take for my knees after a long ride?" About alcohol, ruefully: "A pint and a glass every night does add up. I can cut back in the week." About a rate tablet: "Will it slow me down on the bike? And do I take it with my blood pressure tablet?" If digoxin is suggested: "My dad was on that at the end, when he was bedbound. Is that right for someone on a bike every day?" If a shock to the heart is mentioned: "Then I wouldn't need the blood thinner, would I?"
- ●If the doctor arranges an examination, a scan or a specialist, sends her to hospital, gives vague safety netting or asks her to start today:
- ●Reaction: She will come in but declines to take her own pulse or blood pressure on camera: "I'd only get it wrong." About a scan or specialist: "Will I hear before the trip?" Told to go to hospital today: "But I feel completely fine. Is it really that serious?" Given vague safety netting: "Worried about what, exactly?" If her fear and her cycling have been addressed with real figures and a practical plan, she agrees to start: "If those are the numbers, I'd be daft not to." If not: "I'd rather go away and think about it."
Mark Scheme
Domain 1: Data Gathering and Diagnosis
Domain 2: Clinical Management and Medical Complexity
Domain 3: Relating to Others
Clinical Learning Points
The Core Dilemma and the Model Plan
- ●Rosemary feels well, hopes the monitor is faulty and fears blood thinners after a clubmate's brain bleed. The skill is explaining that atrial fibrillation (AF) needs treating even without symptoms, giving honest numbers, and keeping her cycling at the centre of a safe plan.
- ●Model answer: confirm AF found incidentally, stable and suitable for primary care. Calculate her stroke and bleeding risk and offer a direct oral anticoagulant (DOAC) at the right dose. Stop the ibuprofen and cut alcohol. Start a rate controlling tablet suited to an active person. Examine her in person and arrange an echocardiogram. Give a head injury plan, review dates and a clear safety net. Leave the decision with her.
- ●Also acceptable: starting the DOAC today or after a written information leaflet and a short wait; a beta blocker or a rate limiting calcium channel blocker for rate control; early advice or referral to cardiology if the anticoagulant is not delayed; either stroke risk score used by current guidelines.
Recognising AF and Deciding Where to Manage It
- ●NICE NG196 asks for pulse palpation and a 12 lead ECG to confirm AF, with or without symptoms. Hers shows AF at 118. Many people feel nothing, and her bike computer readings of about 180 on hills are a real clue.
- ●NICE CKS advises emergency admission for instability, a rate over 150 or under 40 with severe symptoms, decompensated heart failure, stroke or TIA, or an acute trigger. AF of unknown onset in a stable person is managed in primary care.
- ●Rosemary is stable, symptom free and well below 150, so primary care is right. Hospital today adds nothing.
- ●History that changes management: previous stroke or TIA, diabetes, heart failure, vascular disease, bleeding, kidney disease, antiplatelets, NSAIDs, alcohol, thyroid disease and valve disease. Moderate to severe mitral stenosis or a mechanical valve means warfarin, not a DOAC. Her records miss ibuprofen two or three days a week and alcohol of about 16 to 20 units rather than 10.
Stroke Risk
- ●NICE NG196 recommends the CHA2DS2 VASc score for AF, symptomatic or not. Points: heart failure 1, hypertension 1, age 75 or over 2, diabetes 1, stroke, TIA or thromboembolism 2, vascular disease 1, age 65 to 74 1, female sex 1.
- ●Rosemary scores 3 (hypertension, age, sex). CKS quotes about 3.2% a year of stroke or other thromboembolism untreated at that score.
- ●NICE NG196 1.6.3: offer a DOAC at 2 or more. The 2024 European guideline uses CHA2DS2 VA, which drops the point for sex. She would score 2 and the recommendation is the same. NICE has not adopted it.
Bleeding Risk, Falls and Numbers
- ●NICE recommends the ORBIT score: 2 points each for low haemoglobin and previous bleeding, 1 each for age over 74, eGFR under 60 and antiplatelet use. It targets modifiable risks and is not a reason to withhold treatment.
- ●Rosemary scores 0, about 1.7 major bleeds per 100 patient years (CKS).
- ●NICE NG196 1.6.8: do not withhold anticoagulation because of age or risk of falls. Falls are rarely a cause of major haemorrhage. DOACs roughly halve intracranial bleeding compared with warfarin (Ruff, 2014).
- ●Warfarin cuts AF stroke by about 64% and aspirin by only about 22% (Hart, 2007). For her, about 3 in 100 women like her would have a stroke or clot in a year untreated and an anticoagulant would prevent around two. Around 2 in 100 have a major bleed on treatment, most not in the brain.
- ●Natural frequencies ("out of 100 women like you") suit a patient who asks for numbers. Use her mother's stroke gently.
- ●Modifiable risks (NG196 1.2.3): ibuprofen, alcohol above limits and blood pressure control.
Choosing and Prescribing the Anticoagulant
- ●NICE NG196 names apixaban, dabigatran, edoxaban and rivaroxaban without ranking them. NHS England's 2024 advice asks for the best value choice, with generic apixaban and rivaroxaban joint first. A vitamin K antagonist is for a mechanical valve, moderate to severe mitral stenosis, antiphospholipid syndrome or where a DOAC is unsuitable.
- ●Doses for her (67, 64 kg, creatinine clearance 69 mL/min by Cockcroft Gault): apixaban 5 mg twice daily (2.5 mg needs two of age 80 or over, weight 60 kg or less, creatinine 133 micromol/L or more); rivaroxaban 20 mg once daily with food; edoxaban 60 mg once daily; dabigatran 150 mg twice daily. Reduce a dose only when a licensed criterion is met.
- ●Baseline tests are a blood count, renal and liver function and clotting screen. Hers are normal.
- ●Advice: no INR tests; protection wears off within 12 to 24 hours so doses must not be missed; never double up; carry the alert card; tell dentists and pharmacists.
- ●NG196 1.6.14: do not offer aspirin alone for stroke prevention in AF.
Rate Control for an Active Patient
- ●NICE NG196 1.7.1 and 1.7.2: rate control is first line in most people. Offer a standard beta blocker (not sotalol) or a rate limiting calcium channel blocker, chosen by symptoms, comorbidities and preference.
- ●Start low, for example bisoprolol 1.25 to 2.5 mg or atenolol 25 to 50 mg daily, and titrate to a resting rate under 110 (CKS).
- ●Diltiazem or verapamil should replace amlodipine, not be added to it, and must be avoided if heart failure is possible, so a beta blocker is simpler until her echocardiogram is back. Do not combine a beta blocker with verapamil.
- ●NG196 1.7.4: digoxin alone is for people who do little exercise, because it controls the rate poorly on exertion, exactly when hers runs away. Amiodarone is not for long term use.
- ●Beta blockers cause tiredness, cold hands and a lower peak heart rate, which a keen cyclist will notice.
Rhythm Control, Echocardiography and Referral
- ●She needs an in person review for a murmur, heart failure signs and a manual blood pressure. NICE NG136 says to measure manually when the pulse is irregular, because automated monitors can be inaccurate.
- ●NG196 1.3.1: echocardiography when it matters for long term management or structural disease is suspected.
- ●NG196 1.7.7: consider rhythm control if symptoms continue after rate control. For AF over 48 hours or of unknown duration, delay cardioversion until she has had at least 3 weeks of anticoagulation (1.8.6). Catheter ablation is considered if drugs fail or are unsuitable.
- ●Referral now to a cardiology or rhythm clinic is reasonable if anticoagulation and rate control start in the meantime.
- ●Restoring sinus rhythm does not remove the need for anticoagulation. NG196 1.11.1 says not to stop it solely because AF is no longer detected.
Cycling and Daily Life on an Anticoagulant
- ●No UK guideline tells people on anticoagulants to stop exercising, and road cycling with a helmet is generally acceptable. The European Society of Cardiology 2020 sports guideline advises against trauma prone sports, so avoiding racing, fast descents or off road riding is reasonable.
- ●Sensible measures: helmet, phone and alert card, telling someone her route, firm pressure on cuts.
- ●NICE NG232 lists anticoagulant treatment as a reason for emergency department assessment after any head injury, with a CT head scan considered within 8 hours. Any knock to the head means A&E the same day.
- ●Driving: DVLA guidance requires notification only if the arrhythmia causes or is likely to cause incapacity. She has none, so she can drive.
- ●Alcohol within 14 units a week lowers bleeding risk and may reduce AF. For her knees, NICE NG226 offers a topical NSAID first, absorbed far less than tablets. Paracetamol suits infrequent short term use.
Follow Up and Safety Netting
- ●Review within a week of starting rate control for heart rate, manual blood pressure and side effects. Review after about a month on the DOAC, then yearly with blood count, renal and liver function and a stroke and bleeding risk review (NG196 1.6.17). Check again before her trip.
- ●999: sudden facial droop, arm weakness or speech difficulty, chest pain, collapse or severe breathlessness.
- ●A&E the same day: any head injury, black or bloody stools, vomiting blood, or bleeding that will not stop.
- ●Same day practice contact: blood in the urine, recurrent nosebleeds or bleeding gums, dizziness or marked tiredness on the new tablet.
Common Mistakes in This Station
- ●Accepting that the monitor is faulty or that the rhythm is a harmless effect of fitness.
- ●Not calculating the stroke and bleeding scores, or leaving out her hypertension or sex.
- ●Withholding anticoagulation because she cycles, has fallen or fears bleeding, or offering aspirin as a gentler option, or under dosing the DOAC.
- ●Telling her to stop cycling or cancel the trip instead of giving a head injury plan.
- ●Missing the ibuprofen and the true alcohol intake.
- ●Choosing digoxin for a woman who rides 50 miles a week, or adding diltiazem on top of amlodipine.
- ●Relying on home monitor readings and never examining her.
- ●Telling her the anticoagulant can stop if the rhythm is corrected.
- ●Answering her request for numbers with "a small risk", and safety netting with "come back if you are worried".
Further reading
From the PCCS Academy, the Primary Care Cardiovascular Society’s learning modules for primary care.
Free for practising healthcare professionals. You need a PCCS account to open these. Join the PCCS
Mapped to the RCGP curriculum topic: Cardiovascular Health.
← Back to Free SCA Practice Cases