Care Home Nurse Asking for Something to Calm An Agitated Resident with Dementia — Free SCA Practice Case
Care home nurse asking for something to calm an agitated resident with dementia
Station Timer
Golden Minute
Initial Introduction
•Introduce yourself
•Ask an open question — "How can I help you today?"
•Listen — don't interrupt
•Catch early cues
Data Gathering
History, ICE & Diagnosis
Clinical Management
Diagnosis, Plan & Decisions
Safety Net
Follow-up & Close
Five cases are free: a live 12-minute consultation with an AI patient each, marked, and no card.
Materials for Candidate
Please review before starting the consultation
Full Name
Hilda Skerritt
Age
84 years
Consultation Type
TelephoneAge
84
Situation
Telephone Consultation. Hilda moved into Fernbank Nursing Home three weeks ago and registered with the practice.
Reason for Encounter
"Mrs Skerritt is getting very agitated in the evenings. Can we have something to calm her down?"
Medical Records (Hilda Skerritt)
- ●PMH: Alzheimer's disease, diagnosed two years ago. Hypertension. Osteoarthritis of both knees. Bilateral hearing loss.
- ●Medications: Donepezil 10 mg once daily. Amlodipine 5 mg once daily.
- ●Allergies: NKDA.
- ●Social: Widowed. Son is next of kin. Weight 56 kg on admission.
Patient Script
For the friend playing the patient role
Character Overview: You are Emmanuel Danquah, 43, a registered nurse and the nurse in charge of the first floor dementia unit at Fernbank Nursing Home. You are ringing about a resident, Hilda Skerritt, who is 84 and has Alzheimer's disease. You have been in charge of this unit for a few months and today it is you and two carers for fifteen residents. You are kind, tired and polite, and you speak quickly. You honestly believe that something to settle Hilda would be kind to her and to the other residents. You have worked in homes where sedatives were put in drinks and you do not know the rules about capacity. You get a little defensive if you feel blamed, but you listen if the doctor is calm and gives you something practical for tonight. You never suggest a cause for her distress beyond "the dementia and the move".
Opening Sentence: "Hello, doctor, it's Emmanuel, the nurse in charge at Fernbank Nursing Home. I'm ringing about Mrs Hilda Skerritt. She's eighty four, she has Alzheimer's and she came to us three weeks ago. She's getting very agitated in the evenings and I wondered if you could prescribe something to calm her down. Something we can put in her tea, because she won't take tablets from us."
History if Asked (Data Gathering Phase)
- ●The agitation: "About a week now. She's fine in the mornings and most of the afternoon. Then from late afternoon through the evening she gets worked up. She calls out 'I want to go home, somebody help me', walks up and down the corridor and bangs on the keypad door at the end of the unit. She says she's got to get home and do the dinners before they all come in. It goes on for hours. She dozes in her armchair after lunch, then she's wide awake, and she's up once or twice in the night."
- ●How she was before: "The first two weeks were better than we expected. She ate with the others, joined in the music session and was chatty. Never aggressive before this week."
- ●The carer being hit: "Four days ago a carer was helping her up from her armchair to take her to the toilet. Hilda swung her arm and caught her on the forearm. No mark, but the carer was shaken. It's the only time."
- ●Leaving the unit: "Twice she's followed a visitor towards the main door, and once a carer found her at the top of the stairs. Nobody's been hurt."
- ●What's going on at that time: "It's our busiest stretch. The tea trolley, handover, the television on loud. Sitting with her works for a few minutes. She hates being told to sit down and gets louder."
- ●Refusing tablets: "She took them fine for the first two weeks. This week she's turned her head away or pushed the pot out of the carer's hand most evenings. She says 'I don't need those, I'm not ill'. She doesn't seem to understand what they're for. She does drink her tea, that's why I thought of that."
Ideas, Concerns, Expectations
Gating note: Emmanuel does not raise any of the following himself. Each part comes out only when the doctor asks what he thinks is behind it, what worries him, or what he was hoping for.
- ●Ideas: He thinks it is the dementia and the move. "They all get worse in the evenings, it's just how it is. She's frightened and in a strange place. A bit of something to take the edge off would be kind." He assumes she cannot decide about her tablets. "With her dementia she can't understand them, can she?"
- ●Concerns: He fears someone will get hurt, either a carer or Hilda on the stairs. Other residents are being kept awake. "If an agency carer gets hit they won't come back, and then I'm on my own." Once the doctor mentions pain or bowels, he is embarrassed: "Oh no. That's our miss. I'll have to write it up."
- ●Expectations: He expects a prescription today for something like lorazepam or haloperidol, as a liquid or a crushable tablet, sent by the pharmacy so it can start tonight. "To be honest, I didn't think you'd need to see her."
If Asked: Medical History and Medications
Gating note: Emmanuel answers each of these plainly when the doctor asks about it.
- ●Health problems: "Alzheimer's, blood pressure, arthritis in both knees, and she's quite deaf."
- ●Medicines on our chart: "Donepezil and amlodipine, both on the evening round. Nothing else, no as required ones, no sleeping tablets. Nothing has changed since she came."
- ●Paracetamol: "Her son told us at admission that she took paracetamol at home, two tablets four times a day, from a pack the carers kept in the kitchen. It was bought over the counter, so it wasn't on the list from the pharmacy and we never started it."
- ●Weight and allergies: "Fifty six kilos when she came in. No known allergies."
- ●Hearing and sight: "She wears her glasses. Her hearing aid for the right ear hasn't been in since she arrived. I'll ask her son."
- ●Capacity, power of attorney and family: "Nobody has assessed her capacity, not formally. I haven't seen any power of attorney paperwork in her file, but I haven't gone looking. Her son is down as next of kin."
Social History and Lifestyle Impact
- ●Hilda: A widow. She lived alone until three weeks ago with carers calling four times a day. Her son arranged the move after she left the gas on twice and got lost walking to the shops. She was a sewing machinist in a clothing factory for over thirty years and likes strong tea with two sugars and the radio. Her room is bare because her son's photographs are still in a bag in the wardrobe.
- ●Her son: He visits once a week and she is calmer while he is there. He feels guilty about the move. He knows nothing about the request: "I didn't want to worry him, and honestly he might say no."
- ●The unit: You are on duty all of today and tomorrow. The practice home round is not until later in the week. The home's homely remedies policy includes paracetamol for a couple of days, and the pharmacy delivers the same day if a prescription is sent early in the afternoon.
If Asked: Associated Symptoms
Gating note: Emmanuel answers only when asked. Observations are read from this morning's chart. If asked to examine Hilda or feel her tummy, he says he is not the right person and would feel better with someone seeing her properly.
- ●If asked about pain: "She rubs her knees and says 'my legs, my legs' now and again. She winces and grabs the chair arms when we stand her up. She can't really tell us how bad it is."
- ●If asked about bowels: "The chart says she hasn't opened her bowels for five days. She's not on any laxative. No vomiting, no leaking that we've noticed, and I don't think her tummy's swollen."
- ●If asked about urine or burning: "She hasn't complained of burning, she's passing urine as normal and there've been no new accidents. We did a dip last night because she was unsettled and it was negative."
- ●If asked about observations: "Temperature 36.8, pulse 82 and regular, blood pressure 134 over 78, breathing 16, sats 96 on air, sugar 6.4."
- ●If asked about confusion, drowsiness or change: "She doesn't know where she is, but that's the same as when she came. She's not drowsy or hard to wake and she knows her son. The only change is the evenings."
- ●If asked about eating and drinking: "About half of each meal, and roughly a litre of fluid a day when we prompt her."
- ●If asked about seeing things, cough, breathlessness, fever, falls or sore skin: "No, none of that."
Responses to Management (The Negotiation Phase)
- ●If the doctor declines to prescribe a sedative for her tea:
- ●Reaction: Frustrated and worried about tonight. "So what am I meant to do? I've got two carers for the whole unit." He pushes once: "What about a tiny dose of haloperidol, or lorazepam? Isn't that safer than her hitting someone?" If the doctor offers to see her in person today or tomorrow morning: relieved. "Yes please, I'm here all day." If the doctor offers only a phone review later in the week: "That's days away. She'll have another four evenings like this."
- ●If the doctor explains the risks of antipsychotics:
- ●Reaction: Surprised. "I didn't know it could raise the risk of a stroke. So when would you ever use one?" He asks how long it would last.
- ●If the doctor raises capacity, hidden medicines or a best interests meeting:
- ●Reaction: Defensive, then curious. "I've worked in homes where the GP prescribed it for the drink and nobody batted an eyelid." If told that dementia alone does not mean she cannot decide: "I didn't realise it was that strict. Who has to be at this meeting? And what do we do tonight if she's lashing out?"
- ●If the doctor says her son needs to be told:
- ●Reaction: Hesitant. "He's feeling guilty enough about putting her in here, and he might say no." If told the call is to ask for his help with her routine, photographs and hearing aid: "Fair enough. Would you rather speak to him yourself?" He agrees to ring him today.
- ●If the doctor suggests painkillers, a laxative or changes to her routine:
- ●Reaction: Practical questions. "Can I give her something for her knees tonight, and how much? How long will the laxative take? Do I just skip her evening tablets?" If asked what helps: "She'd love a job at teatime, she worked a machine in a factory all her life and never sat still. And she's fine in the morning, she takes a drink and a biscuit with no bother."
- ●If the doctor gives vague safety netting such as "ring us if she gets worse":
- ●Reaction: Wants specifics. "Worse how? When do I ring 999 and when do I ring the surgery or out of hours? The night nurse needs to know." He repeats back what he is told and asks when someone will ring him back.
Mark Scheme
Domain 1: Data Gathering and Diagnosis
Domain 2: Clinical Management and Medical Complexity
Domain 3: Relating to Others
Clinical Learning Points
The core dilemma and the model plan
- ●Emmanuel wants a sedative that staff can put in Hilda's tea. The task is to decline hidden sedation, find out why an 84 year old woman with Alzheimer's disease is distressed in the evenings, treat what is treatable, and give a short staffed unit a safe plan for tonight. The National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) guideline NG97 on dementia says to assess for pain, delirium and other causes first, and to offer psychosocial and environmental measures.
- ●Model plan: decline the hidden sedative and explain why; see her in person today or by the next morning for a delirium assessment, pain assessment, rectal examination and medication review; restart regular analgesia and start a laxative; agree non drug measures with the home; deal with the refused tablets openly; involve her son; explain what covert medication and any antipsychotic would require; give specific safety netting and review within days.
- ●Also acceptable: a visit by a GP, advanced clinical practitioner or community frailty team; paracetamol, a topical anti inflammatory or both; any guideline supported laxative regimen; paracetamol tonight under the home's homely remedies policy; early telephone advice from older adults mental health services.
Looking for the cause of distress
- ●Behavioural and psychological symptoms of dementia (BPSD) include agitation, calling out, wandering and aggression, and usually express an unmet need. Risk factors for delirium in dementia include sensory impairment, pain, dehydration, faecal impaction and an unfamiliar environment.
- ●Hilda has several at once: a recent move, a noisy teatime, a bare room, no hearing aid, pain on standing, lost paracetamol and five days without a bowel motion. None calls for a sedative.
- ●A trial of stepped analgesia cited by NICE Clinical Knowledge Summaries (CKS) found agitation improved by about 17 per cent, similar to antipsychotics. The British National Formulary (BNF) lists agitation, aggression and sleep disorders among common donepezil effects, so include it in the medication review.
Delirium, infection and the dipstick
- ●NICE guideline CG103 says to assess anyone at risk who shows changes over hours or days, using the 4AT (4 A's Test) tool, and to manage delirium first if it is hard to tell from dementia. Hilda's observations are normal and her confusion is unchanged since arrival, so delirium is less likely, but a week of new evening distress still needs a 4AT. Any competent health or social care practitioner can do it, so the nurse could complete one today.
- ●Do not diagnose a urine infection from behaviour alone. CKS advises considering infection in a woman over 65 when there is isolated new dysuria or two or more urinary or non specific symptoms, and advises against dipstick testing to make the diagnosis, sending a mid stream urine (MSU) for culture when symptoms suggest infection. Hilda has no urinary symptoms and no fever, so antibiotics are not indicated.
Pain and constipation
- ●NG97 advises a structured observational pain assessment tool for people who cannot report pain (the Abbey Pain Scale is widely used), a stepwise treatment protocol and repeat assessment. Restarting the regular paracetamol she took at home is a reasonable first step. The BNF gives 0.5 to 1 g every 4 to 6 hours, maximum 4 g a day, with adjustment below 50 kg or with malnutrition. Hilda weighs 56 kg.
- ●NICE guideline NG226 on osteoarthritis says to offer a topical NSAID (non steroidal anti inflammatory drug) for knee osteoarthritis and not to routinely offer paracetamol, because evidence of benefit is not strong. For a woman who cannot report pain and was stable on paracetamol a time limited restart is defensible, and a topical NSAID is the NG226 first choice, alone or alongside. Strong opioids add constipation and confusion. Either route earns credit.
- ●For constipation CKS advises checking for faecal loading or impaction, including a rectal examination, then stepped oral laxatives: bulk forming first, an osmotic such as a macrogol next, and a stimulant if stools are soft but hard to pass. For loading it suggests a high dose macrogol, then suppositories or a mini enema. A macrogol is practical here, but any CKS route is acceptable.
Non drug approaches
- ●NG97 recommends psychosocial and environmental interventions, personalised activities for agitation, and daylight and exercise for sleep problems.
- ●Practical measures: ask her son for her life story and routine; give her a teatime job such as folding napkins or laying tables, drawing on her thirty years at a factory machine; put up her photographs; keep the same carers at teatime and cut noise during the tea trolley and handover; encourage daylight and activity by day; get her hearing aid back in use; walk with her rather than telling her to sit down; check hunger, thirst and the toilet.
Antipsychotics and benzodiazepines
- ●NG97 says to offer antipsychotics only to people at risk of harming themselves or others, or with agitation, hallucinations or delusions causing severe distress; to discuss benefits and harms with the person and family first; to use the lowest effective dose for the shortest possible time; and to reassess at least every 6 weeks. CKS adds that risperidone and haloperidol are the only licensed antipsychotics for these symptoms and should be started under specialist supervision.
- ●The harms are why. CKS, quoting product information, reports deaths about 1.6 to 1.7 times those on placebo (about 4.5 per cent against 2.6 per cent over roughly 10 weeks) and about three times as many cerebrovascular events with some atypicals. Hilda is not at that point: her causes are untreated, non drug measures have not been tried, and the one blow came as she was stood up on painful knees.
- ●NG97 does not address benzodiazepines. The BNF's STOPP criteria (a screening tool for inappropriate prescribing in older people) flag them in people prone to falls, the BNF describes paradoxical hostility and aggression, and CKS lists long acting benzodiazepines among sedatives to use with caution in dementia. Treat them as generally best avoided.
Capacity, covert medication and restraint
- ●The Mental Capacity Act 2005 (MCA) presumes capacity. It is judged for each decision, with all practicable help given, and neither an unwise decision nor a diagnosis of dementia shows lack of capacity. Nobody has yet assessed Hilda's capacity.
- ●NICE guideline SC1 on care home medicines and the Care Quality Commission (CQC) say covert administration should not happen if the person has capacity. If she lacks capacity for that decision, the process is a best interests meeting with care staff, the prescriber, a pharmacist and a family member or advocate (which can be remote), recorded reasons, pharmacist advice because crushing or mixing can alter a medicine, and regular review. The CQC adds that it is likely to be appropriate only where the person actively refuses, lacks capacity and the medicine is essential.
- ●MCA section 4 requires consultation, where practicable, with anyone caring for her or interested in her welfare and with any attorney, so her son must be involved and the file checked for a health and welfare attorney.
- ●Neither refused tablet is essential tonight; the better question is whether another time of day would work. A sedative given secretly to control behaviour, rather than to treat a diagnosed condition, is widely regarded as chemical restraint. Under MCA section 6, restraint includes restricting her liberty of movement and is protected only if reasonably believed necessary to prevent harm to her and proportionate to it. The CQC also asks homes to consider whether covert sedatives contribute to deprivation of liberty.
Tonight, safety netting and follow up
- ●This is not an emergency admission, and hospital would raise her risk of delirium, but it should not wait for the routine home round either. The choice is in person assessment today or next morning, with treatment started today.
- ●Tonight: paracetamol under the homely remedies policy until a prescription arrives, the laxative, a carer with her at teatime, and her kept away from the stairs without physical restraint. If she lashes out, staff should step back and de escalate.
- ●Safety netting: 999 for collapse or unresponsiveness, a fall with head injury, new facial droop, limb weakness or speech difficulty, chest pain, severe breathlessness or a seizure. A same day call to the practice or out of hours for fever, new drowsiness, refusing fluids, vomiting, a swollen or painful tummy, or sudden worsening of confusion.
- ●Review in a few days for pain, bowels and evenings, and update the medicines chart. If distress persists, seek older adults mental health advice.
Common candidate mistakes
- ●Agreeing to lorazepam or haloperidol by telephone "just for tonight", or refusing with no plan so the nurse has nothing for the evening.
- ●Sending Hilda to hospital for evening agitation without red flags.
- ●Starting antibiotics because of a behaviour change, or treating a negative dip as proof that nothing acute is happening.
- ●Not asking what she took at home, so the missing paracetamol and the constipation are never found.
- ●Saying she lacks capacity because she has dementia, or leaving her son out.
- ●Safety netting that says to ring if she gets worse.
- ●Lecturing about the Mental Capacity Act without a practical plan for two carers.
Mapped to the RCGP curriculum topic: Older Adults.
← Back to Free SCA Practice Cases